NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner - Smokin Topaz, Brown Eyeliner

Amazing pencil! The brown color is rich and can be used as an eye liner as well as kajal. It stays on for a long time but can be smudged for a smokey eye. Overall great product for the price. NYX hardly disappoints with their products and I will be definitely trying more colors.

Edit: bought 3 times. 2nd time lacked pigment, but they sent me a free replacement and it was good. I got the NYX Mechnical Eyeliner in the onyx (black) shade. It is absolutely stunning! It is definitely washable, not waterproof. This is what I was seeking as I do not like using makeup remover and prefer for all my makeup to wash away in the shower with a gentle facial cleanser. I find that makeup removers can be harsh on skin and can tear some eyelashes out. The NYX eyeliner can smudge throughout the day, but it takes a LOT to smudge. I took two naps, had wind blown in my face, and planted a tree and it remained perfect on my oily eyeliner with no primer. It did not last as long on my waterline, but that's to be expected, probably a few hours max. I haven't worn eyeliner in years now but I remembered recently that I really enjoyed applying it back in the day. I was shocked how easy it was to apply. I remember I used to use a product called Rimmel Scandal Eyes and this NYX eyeliner is incredible comparatively. It is so pigmented yet more smudge resistant. It glides on smoothly and is easy to shape. It is firm and does not seem like it will break. I am very satisfied with this product and highly recommend to anyone looking for a very pigmented pencil eyeliner that is washable yet smudge resistant! Great price as well.

Works great, goes on smoothly. Downside is that it arrived broken :(

This is a great eyeliner that goes on very smoothly and last all day

Ultra fine point, ultra dark brown. Very creamy but stays put once applied

I have been struggling trying to find a dark navy blue/black eyeliner with no results. I used to buy it from Esteé Lauder, and they stopped making it years ago. Oh what joy it was to FINALLY find one just like it with this wonderful product! It’s super dark blue/black color that wonderfully pigmented and goes on smooth. The price is so affordable. I absolutely love this eyeliner and have always found NYX products great!

I was very excited about the rich, deep black in this product -- just what I was looking for ... until I discovered that it broke off starting with just the third time I used it! In addition, there just didn't seem to be much of the product itself at all, inside the long pencil tube. Pretty much a waste of my money to be that small of a supply! I'm moving on to try another brand now. (Would have only given this one or two stars, but this page won't let me give it less than three. Really!!??)

A very cool golden taupe brownish magical color. Staying power. Doesn’t smear. Looks pretty under the lower lashes. I’ll do black liner, some shadow and mascara- swipe a thin line under my lower lashes. I love the subtle glittery shimmer. I’m middle aged and I need some sparkle! It’s subtle and interesting. I will be buying this again. It’s attractive and interesting and I think it’s fun without being loud, clowny, glitter faced or juvenile. I might try this in another color. So far, this color is great and the liner has good behavior.