MAYBELLINENew York TattooStudio Liquid Ink Eyeliner, Ink Black, 0.08 fl. oz.

It goes on easily, and stays on long (48 hours for me). No chipping or flaking in that time. The wand is made so you can do thin or thick lines. I do one upper eyelid, then the other. By the time I go back to the first eye, the liner is dry. If you make a mistake, it's not hard to clean if you get it right away. If you leave it until it dries, you'll need makeup remover or soap. Good value for the money. Smooth texture. Performs well.

I used Maybelline eye liner for many years and then just stopped using any eye liner. I decided to try the brown/black again and love it as much as I did when I used it many years ago. Easy to use, looks natural and doesn't irritate my eyes.

Bought this after not being able to find the Maybeline Ultra Liner I have used for decades, and what a HUGE disappointment! This flakes off after only two hours! Had to throw it away and drive 30 miles to a store to find a new product. You should have discontinued this and kept the Ultra Liner that actually worked well!!

Goes on easy and stays on with no smugging.

These go on really easily, even for someone who hasn't used liquid liner in a while. I like the little felt tip brush, although some may prefer a true multi-bristle brush. You have to use a light hand to get a nice solid line. If you press too hard, you can end up with a line that is darker on the edge and lighter down the middle.They usually stay on really well, with a weird caveat. It does not melt or smear, but it does roll up like dry erase ink. It is truly waterproof and (surprisingly) even resistant to oil cleansers, at first. You can rub and rub at it with an oil cleanser or eye makeup remover and it won't budge at first, and then suddenly comes off in one piece.I found it to work very much like that on my eyes too; most of the time it stays put really well, but when it doesn't, it will just vanish suddenly in one section. It doesn't smear or drip. This also happens sometimes if you go over the same section more than once with the brush, as if the color picks up the previous bit and takes it away with it. But, that doesn't happen all that often.I bought black and both browns (Rustic and Henna) to compare them. Black is as expected. The two browns are very much alike when you put them; the caps indicate that Rustic is a warmer, lighter shade than Henna, and that is true to some extent, but they go on and dry down almost identical. They're just a little lighter and warmer/redder than the brown Lasting Drama Gel in the little glass jar, but they blend well enough that they can be used together.

I love the color, pigmentation, applicator, and that it’s liquid.Everyone only sells black liner, (or liner that says is brown but is actually black) and that’s just way too much contrast on my very pale skin, so I love that this is actually brown.It is also very pigmented and covers in one swipe (if you do it right the way you want it the first time). If you add another stroke though, the new stroke will ruin the previous stroke.BUT this product dries very fast in the component so you can’t use it for too long before having to throw it away.AND if you mess up you can’t just remove the tiny speck of liner you messed up. This dries like Elmer’s glue and literally the whole thing peels off/ and tiny balls of liner glue gather and doesn’t look good. If you’re me, getting the little balled up liner glue off disturbs the surrounding eye make up and it’s just a whole getting ready nightmare.

Why did you pick this product vs others?:This is honestly my favorite eyeliner! I won’t purchase any other!The eyeliner stays put and does not run- waterproof. it can be easily removed with makeup remover.Waterproof:Yes!Durability:Stays on all dayColor:Black

The easiest eyeliner to use. And I'm 68 and love eyeliner.