New York Lash Discovery Mini-Brush Waterproof Mascara, Very Black, 0.16 fl. oz.

I wear contacts. I swim. I sweat. I wear greasy/oily sunscreens. My lashes have blonde tips. I feel absolutely feel naked without mascara. However, my lifestyle is not compatible with it. This is one of the most truly waterproof mascaras on the market. Absolutely most comfortable with contacts. I've tried them all. It's also fairly easy to remove with micellar water. Is it the most dramatic? Not entirely. But it's a lot more dramatic than you'd expect. It's amazing with curled lashes. The formula seems to hold the curl well, and doesn't weigh the lashes down. Zero clumping. The brush really does help get every single lash. The overall effect is a very bright, wide eye sort of lash. Very natural looking.... and I don't mean natural as in "doesn't do anything" but more like... doesn't look overly made up. It's fantastic for an everyday look, especially if you need long wearing. It's the best for lower lashes, and sometimes when I use a more intense mascara on my upper lashes, I still use this on the lower lashes. It's truly a uniquely amazing mascara.

I like the tiny brush for my light lashes! I was trying all the products that promise to make your lashes look thick and long, but all I ever got was that clumpy, spiky effect. This is fantastic - it brings my lashes out by giving them color, but they look natural and don't stick together. I wish I had discovered this a long time ago!

These are great for short asian lashes. The brush makes it easy to get every lash. Waterproof and easy to remove. They do not thicken your lashes tho.

I like the product. I don't like that there's not very much product in the tube. It didn't last long before I had to repurchase a new one. ;BUT THE QUALITY OF THE MASCARA IS DEFINITELY GOOD. It gets those fine little lashes and separates them well. I say it's worth the purchase even if there's not alot of product in the tube. I'll buy it again. I only use it along with the other maybelline illegal lengths mascara which happens to have a fair amount of product and is the best mascara I've ever used. Illegal Lengths is better than department store mascara that costs $40.00. Its Lengthening , adds a little extension to your lashes but keeps it natural looking. You should definitely try the Ilegal Length version by Maybelline because it's the best. Not clumpy lasts a good duration and it's well combined with this product under review.

I have tried MANY different mascaras and this is the BEST one! I have short .. barely there lashes and this one really grabs those little lashes. I also have very sensitive eyes and this mascara doesn’t make my eyes tear. No smudging either. This will be my forever mascara!!

My friend recommended this specific mascara - raved about it, in fact - so, I was on the hunt for new mascara and decided to give it a go. I do not like it at all. The wand is the tiniest thing ever so there is zero elongating happening and the brush does not separate your lashes at all. The mascara itself is very dry, very dry, as if it's old. In all fairness, I've never found a mascara that has ever made me completely happy (I'm 43 so... yikes). This is probably my least favorite of all time. Maybe if you have long, thick lashes but I don't have either. I gave it 3 stars because I know others enjoy it and don't want to kill their star ratings because I'm picky.

I have short, straight Asian lashes and this currently is my go-to for the following reasons: 1. It does not clump. The thinner wand and the shorter bristles make this mascara great for lengthening your lashes, giving you the perfect eye-popping effect that still looks natural and clean. 2. It retains your curl pretty well for how easy it is to wash off. Of all the waterproof mascaras I’ve tried, this is one of the easier ones to wash off (you still need to use an oil-based cleanser/makeup remover). However, I generally find that the easier it is to wash off, the less lifted/curled your lashes will stay. This is still somewhat true for this mascara, but you could say the correlation is not as prominent. The curl falls to a small degree, and in my opinion, my lashes still look very lifted as you can see in the picture, even after the lashes settle. 3. It doesn’t smudge much, if at all. Just try to keep the mascara on your lashes and not your skin when you’re applying. Overall, highly recommend!

Oldie but goody. I have used this brand for years and I love it. Extremely waterproof!