MAYBELLINEEyestudio Lasting Drama Waterproof Matte Gel Pencil Brown Eyeliner Makeup, Glazed Toffee, 1 Count

This product is easy to use and stays in place for a few days. I have been using this eyeliner for awhile and think it has many great qualities like color and is non irritating to my sensitive eyes.

Absolute best eyeliner I've ever tried. Bought more. Smooth, super long lasting, great color.

Smudges and isn't water resistant like it says

Smooth and perfect. The color is what I need it exactly. Perfect brown eye pencil

I love how easily it glides on when you first get it. Once the tip is dull, it’s extremely hard- if impossible to get the tip back. Please make this pencil easy to sharpen!

Maybelline has always been my "go to" brand. I love the gel eyeliners as they last all day, no smudging and are easily removed. HOWEVER, Maybelline has replaced this gel liner with a Tattoo gel liner. It flakes during the day and is horrible to remove. Wish Maybelline would get the message.

Very easy to use. Goes on very smoothly. No tugging

I have a few colors of this. The sapphire is a hard to find bright blue and looks gorgeous. It is hard to sharpen since the pencil is gel-very soft and should be encased in a hard material .I bought a Clinique sharpener for $4 and it solved the problem. You really need a good sharpener not just any.It is truly smudge proof once it sets. Hard to make a winged tip since you can't created a pointed tip out of the pencil . but otherwise its better than the $20 eyeliners out there and since it is soft it will not dry up, another problem I find w/ other eyeliners even expensive ones.