MilaniStay Put Eyeliner - Goal Digger (0.01 Ounce) Cruelty-Free Self-Sharpening Eye Pencil with Built-In Smudger - Line & Define Eyes with High Pigment Shades for Long-Lasting Wear

Why did you pick this product vs others?:I have use this for years because it stays in place without smudging. The color is also just right, not black-looking and not too light.Waterproof:It is truly waterproof. I use it to tightline and sometimes a little comes off in the inner corners, but overall it stays in place. I like that it does not transfer to my lower lash area like some others.Quality:This is consistently good quality and fresh. Functionality:It does what I need it to do, lasts and is easy to apply. It does not tug and is not too dry.

Best eye liner I have ever used. Soft texture, stays put all day. Easy to apply. Most waterproof stuff I tend to be overly sensitive to but not this one. Its really nice.

This is easy to apply. It does not drag your skin. It lasts for a good amount of time and does not smear. I am 76 and have always worn eyeliner . I have tried many different brands and this is working well for me. It is waterproof and the color is a deep brown. I have blue eyes and it highlights the blue. It has a durable foam tip on the end to smudge the line. I am very satisfied with this liner and I will buy again.

Erin Parsons on YouTube recommended the product.. I really like the color, it is easy to apply, didn’t stay on as long as I thought it would,

I love this eyeliner! This is the only eyeliner I’ve been using for years! It stays on and is easy to take off. Sometimes it’s hard to find this in black but I usually get it when I need it

Stays on for sure! I can’t speak highly enough about this eyeliner for the fact that it really stays on! It’s a true black color and I like that you don’t have to sharpen the pencil and it doesn’t break off. This is probably one of the best eyeliners I’ve purchased drugstore wise. I see no need to pay for an expensive Eyeliner. This is great.

Goes on so smoothly! No skipping.

Applies very smooth and evenly. When waterlining or tightlining upper lid, it immediately transfers to lower.Lasts all day, but melts under the eye after a couple hours (I don’t apply under the eye).