Half Caked Totally Tubular Mascara | vegan & cruelty-free, flake-free, smudge-free, clean beauty, easy to remove | 8.5ml… (The Ultimate)

I’ve never been one to rave about mascara but Ive used half caked for over a yr now and every time I get antsy and want to shop around I am so disappointed. If you love a tubing mascara or even just a waterproof mascara- this is it. Stop looking. Just don’t look.1) so affordable. Ive tried $35 mascaras (that sounds crazy now that Ive typed it but I did what I did) and they pale in comparison. Even when you’re nearing the end of your tube, it keeps giving.2) I misspoke… I’ve tried too faced better than s3x mascara which is $40 + and it was terrible. Smudged on my lower lash line no matter what and matter the season. The half caked formula just does not move throughout the day.3) so easy to take off with just warm water and a soft washcloth. That’s it. Lashes feel great afterwards.

This product is very dry and does not do much to extend the lashes. I tried it twice and just didn’t do much me. It felt like it was practically empties out.I was going to return it, but I disposed of the box. I was disappointed with this product.

The formula is very very dry. I was looking for a dupe to the Thrive mascara but this is not it. It does give length but it is very itchy on my eyes and the formula being as dry as it was is not going to do it for me. 3 stars because it does give length and wash off like a tubing mascara should.

Love this mascara but it's already dried out and I haven't even had it a month (Purchased 1/4/24). Hoping I just got a bad batch.

I was really surprised it was a first experience with tubing mascaras. This worked really very well at lengthening and I will re-purchase.

I compared this product to a similar one (Milani highly rated mascara). I applied both mascaras on the same eye on the same day and nothing on the other eye. I applied two coats with each mascara- no primer, no lash curler, nothing else. My Milani mascara actually needs to be replaced and it still looks better than this one. The product is too dry and not much pigment. Pic on the left is this product and pic on the right is my old Milani brand mascara.

So impressed by this product. I was hoping for the best but still skeptical until I actually took the plunge and applied it. I have always worn L’Oreal Double Extend as it’s the only option for non raccoon eyes in my opinion. But I recently turned vegan and I know that it doesn’t just end with what you eat, it’s what you put on your body too. So there began the search for a vegan alternative to the L’Oreal mascara. This it it!! I’m really so thrilled and thankful that it exists. You truly can have it all. Non smudging mascara that makes you look great while being kind to animals and your yourself!

I have very thin lashes and this helps hold the curl of my lashes after I curl them. Not completely but more than a lot of other mascaras I’ve tried. It’s more volumizing than lengthening but I love that. I’m getting more of this when I run out. Definitely tubing and easy to remove. I’ve tried the other trending mascaras but I like this one the most and it doesn’t smudge!