Honest BeautyVibeliner Pencil Eyeliner Harmony (Bronze) | With Jojoba Oil, Meadowfoam Oil, & Macadamia Nut Oil | With built-in smudger, 0.038 Ounce

The Honest Company's eyeliner pencil is an absolute game-changer in the world of cosmetics. I have been using this eyeliner pencil for some time now, and I must say, it has completely won me over. The formula is smooth and creamy, gliding effortlessly across the eyelids without tugging or pulling. The pigmentation is rich and intense, allowing for precise application and creating stunning eye looks. What sets this eyeliner pencil apart is its commitment to using clean and non-toxic ingredients. The Honest Company ensures that their products are free from harsh chemicals and harmful additives, making it a trustworthy and reliable choice for those who prioritize the health of their skin. With its exceptional performance, quality ingredients, and dedication to transparency, the Honest Company's eyeliner pencil easily earns a well-deserved five-star rating.

I received this with the tip broken and jagged wood sticking out. When I tried to sharpen it the same thing happened. I wish they would include a sharpener with this pencil. I tried another sharpener which had a little better success but not 100%. The color is really nice and it stays on well throughout the day with only mild fading. Should be half the price.

I was looking for a replacement for the dark brown Burt’s Bees retractable eyeliner that wasn’t available anymore, and this fit the bill! I had never used pencil eyeliner before, but I was happy that the tip was soft and gentle, similar to the crayon-like texture I was used to. It stays on my eyes well, and the color is rich. My new go-to!

I’m really happy with this eyeliner! It’s exactly what I want! Yes it doesn’t stay on forever but I like that it’s not a perfect line because doing eye make up is not my forte. This goes on so easily where I apply it half of my top lash line at end. I just go back-and-forth a few times and boom! I look like made up! I’m not into heavy make up on a daily basis so this is a perfect eyeliner for me. I’m trusting in the company and this Amazon seller that the ingredients are safe. Would definitely buy again

1. A+ for ingredients, one of the less toxic on the market2. A for formula - very creamy and glides on easily3. B+ for color - nice natural looking plum4. Big fat C for pigment saturation - swatches nicely on the back of your hand, but doesn't translate to the eyes. Pigment is waaaay more sheer on the lids5. Big fat F for staying power - used without primer this pencil lasts about 2-3 hours and then just disappears. With powder underneath or primer, it lasts just a little longer.Bottom line - if you're into natural looking eyeliner that's less toxic, but lasts only long enough to run a couple of errands, go for it. If you need all day staying power this ain't it. The price is also high for the staying power you're getting.

Clean beauty! What can you ask for? The brown is a lighter brown - I’m a used to a more chocolate brown for an eyeliner but it has staying power and doesn’t smudge. And it’s 100% clean according to EWG rating. No complaints!

I was really excited to try this brand because it’s a known for being very healthy and clean. The product comes out beautifully and is easy to apply. But unfortunately, I have raccoon eyes within the hour. It just won’t stay put. I bought two right out of the gate, and I feel extremely disappointed. I don’t want to give up on this brand, but this was a rough start.

I wanted to start doing eyeliner again and bought this. It’s pretty good and can make a pretty liner. I do want to say that because it’s a pen it can have small excess crack of while you are using it. It’s kinda creamy and can be smudged around which can be annoying to some people but I liked it since it has even more ways that I can use it.