Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Navy, 1 count

Really pretty color, goes on nicely but I will caution you to make sure that if you don't want a solid obvious "line" to blend right away or it gets a little more challenging to blend well otherwise. Wears well and all day, never need to reapply. I do not have any problems with it smudging or running, once it's on, it stays put. Washes off nice and easily and if during the day I forget and slightly wipe at my eye, it doesn't smudge either...my mascara on the other hand....that's another review. I like this product and will order again. I have sensitive eyes and this doesn't bother me at all!! I've tried so many "natural" or organic products out there but Almay always comes through. I just wish their eye shadows were better and had better selections.

This is the first time interacting with this seller and I’m happy to say I received my eyeliner on time and ik perfect condition. Recently I had dealt with another seller and two different items shipped two different times were broken with THAT seller however this seller did a splendid job and I couldn’t be happier! The eyeliner works great, it doesn’t irritate my eyes , color is as described and I would definitely order from this seller again! After my initial first orders with another seller having received a broken eyeliner and a broken eyeshadow on two separate occasions I am so very happy to be dealing with a seller who ships promptly, wraps the product well and the item is as described. I would definitely recommend dealing with this seller from my first order and how smoothly it went ! The Almay navy eyeliner is easy to apply, a perfect navy and doesn’t irritate my eyes.

I was quite surprised by this little liner. The gel is actually quite soft and goes on easily and usually this means it doesn't stay on or it runs, but this one doesn't. Granted, you do need a touch up once by afternoon but otherwise, I am very pleased with how it holds up and how it goes on without having to apply too much pressure. My only criticism is that it does not sharpen easily or terribly well but if you only sharpen with a couple of twists, it's ok.

This arrived with just a tiny bit of product peeking up from the pencil. I tried sharpening it but the eyeliner literally falls apart as soon as it leaves its sheath. Tried using it and could not get it to work at all. I'm in my 60s and have quite a bit of experience applying makeup and this is the worst I've seen. I threw it away.

I've been having a lot of allergic reactions to eye makeup recently, so I have been searching for some hypoallergenic eyeliner, pencil and mascara. I'm pretty pleased with this liner overall, and although it does make my eyes feel a little itchy for a few minutes after application, it doesn't cause any redness, wateriness or swelling. However, I wouldn't recommend using it for your waterline. Try to keep it at where your bottom lash line starts and gradually smudge/re-apply the liner until you have achieved the desired look. All in all, I like it!

color is good but I didn't realize the pencil must be sharpened. I would not order again. I have always used almay eyeliner and this is the first one that needs a sharpener. If it were a mechanical pencil I would give it 5 stars

This is a pencil eyeliner, therefore the tip will be as sharp or as blunt as you prefer. It sharpens easily, glides on smoothly, and lasts till you take it off. I am fair skinned with blue/green eyes, I feel like black is too dark for me, and brown is blah. The navy blue is just dark enough to make my eyes stand out, but most people do not realize it is a navy blue eyeliner until I tell them. This is the 3rd one I've purchased.

And it doesn’t give my contacts trouble! My eyes are sensitive to just about everything. Finally! I can wear eyeliner if I want to. You can smoke up a little too, so you don't have to use shadow with it. 😊👍🏼

Would recommend. Stays on all day and lovely colour.

Nice colour and smooth application, absolutely no reaction or irritation

Me encantó!!! No sé corre, dura todo el dia!! Lo encontré en oferta y mas me encantó. Las 3B, bueno, bonito y barato

Eyeliner arrived but it was extended out to full length. Unable to retract it. Colour is as expected & eyeliner does glide on well. Disappointing, the tip has now snapped off using very little pressure. Will endeavour to get replacement/refund

Its excellent