W3LL PEOPLE Fresh Lines Eye Pencil, High-pigment Eyeliner Pencil For Lining & Defining Your Eyes, Smudge-resistant, Vegan & Cruelty-free, Black

I like the safe ingredients in this eyeliner and that it is EWG verified. It is a dark black and goes on smoothly, but it tends to spread by midday and look smeary.

The Well People line of cosmetics is wonderful for people with ingredient sensitivities. I have terrible sensitivities to most drug store line cosmetics like Revlon and Maybelline that use parabens as preservatives. I own and use several products from the Well People line and have not had any reaction. The eye pencil has lots of pigment for all day wearability with only one downside in that it tends to smug over the course of several hours.

Wish the reviews were true. Mine was as dry, hard and crusty as my 99 cent liner I bought. Not good quality at all, especially for this price point. I had really high hopes for this, but let down completely. If you’re looking for beautiful smooth eye liner stick to ud, this is a waste of money.

I love the clean ingredients and goes on good for me, my only issue is how much of the product that breaks off when I try to sharpen it so product is wasted. Happens every time and very frustrating.

This black eyeliner is what I was looking for! It goes on smooth and dark! Im cleaning up my toxic load and choosing cleaner, healthier beauty products using EWG’s app. This one fits the bill. I knocked off a star because I wish it had that little blender tip on the bottom like CoverGirl eyeliner pencils have and also the price is very high for a plain black eyeliner pencil.