JOAHLine Up Liquid Eyeliner with Precision Felt Tip, Fast-Drying & Waterproof, Long Lasting, Smudge Proof Eye Liner, Effortless Control, Biotin Infused, Blackest Black

It’s a must have for me. The thin lines it can create and super black formula is superior to other brands.

Perfect wing due to brush tip… and stays put. For reference I like the physician formula eyeliner and the wet and wild one too … tried other brands like nyx or maybelline ; this one beats them all .

I am an experienced liquid eyeliner wearer. I used Stila for many years, but this is a great dupe. Love it and it lasts!

I used to use the NYX liquid matte liner until they discontinued it. I have tried SEVERAL other liners as a daily replacement and everything else either didn’t have a strong enough pigment, or would clump. This is the first one I’ve found that I enjoy. I also liked the Haus brand, but found that dried up too quickly.

I ordered this 2 months ago and the 1st day I opened the box it was completely dry....I wish I had opened the box sooner so I could have gotten my money back ...no star would have been my choice.....

Yeah cry with this stuff on and you’ll still be good 💕

i have very oily eyelids and eyeliner is never opaque after even two hours wearing it, especially when I go to school, and I've had this on for about 7 1/2 hours and it still looks amazing. i'm shocked

It was definitely smudge and water proof and it was very smooth to put on. My only thing with it is that it doesn't last very long. If you plan using it every once in awhile then this is for you but if you use eyeliner everyday and you don't hesitate to do a dramatic look then I would just find a good liquid liner in a bottle, or buy multiple of these. I used this for 2 weeks and it dried out, sadly.