Beauty Forever Twist Up Lip and Eye Pencil, Lightweight, Matte & Shimmer Finish, Long Lasting, Waterproof, Smudge Proof, Suitable for All Lips and Eye Shapes, Available in 12 Shades 104 Brown

For short uses such as photo shoots etc.But for long day wear I started to look like a panda! Not sure if it is because I have greasy face in general, but the darkness etc is perfect. I would definitely recommend for short uses

I usually use Avon glimmerstick in cosmic brown but this was same day delivery and I urgently needed an eyeliner. I wasn't expecting much, just thought it would be a standard eyeliner and fully expected it to be pretty shite but was pleasantly surprised as it survived tears, rain and a swimming pool despite no claims of being waterproof. It's not as smooth to put on as other eyeliners but I've gotten used to it now and have adapted my methods of application. Helps if you have primer underneath or a cream eyeshadow for smoother application. will definitely buy again.

Using as an eye liner, can smudge a bit but good value, will purchase again

The product arrived with the pencil exposed, no cover on top of it, and pencil had a flat tip.

Smudges everywhere on lips

Not waterproof. Not smudge proof. Not even wear proof. I usually use Avon glimmer stick which stays put all day, I might retouch it to go out in the evening.I applied this liner, drank a coffee, checked my makeup before heading out, & it had all but disappeared! Half a dozen more attempts later, I’ve tried primer underneath & every other trick I know- results the same. Rubbish.

I think that this is a great lip liner. It goes on really well and is nice and soft and pliable so that you can eccentuate your lips. It is also an eye liner which is kind of weird, but hey I will use it on my lips :)

It came quickly, you do need need to top up after a few hour because of eating and drinking but does last longer than I thought.