NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Matte Liquid Liner, Smear-Resistant Eyeliner with Precise Tip - Black

I love this color and it shows up on eyes great and doesn't smear and stays on

I used to loved this eyeliner and its always sold out. When I tried using it this time the color was a bit sheer, the brush was a little messed up, & the product is clumpy! Its like i took a brush to an eyeliner gel instead of a liquid liner and its super dry!I did a swatch test, the first 4 lines from the left are from this liner. The 4 following are a swatch from elf liquid liner. I didn’t even need to swipe of excess liner from the nyx liner bcs there was barely any! The elf liquid liner was practically dripping in comparison…

Love it! It’s easy to apply, lasts all day, has a rich dark black color, and comes with a precise brush for perfect lines.

This eyeliner dries down to a nice matte black finish. However once dry it can be easily peeled away if you accidentally rub your eye especially in the corners of your eyes where there can be moisture. I have sensitive hooded eyes so this is especially true for me. Over an hour or so it becomes a bit crumbly especially in areas where you may have applied a thicker layer. So while technically not smearing it can flake and crumble over the course of the day. Its more noticeable if you like a big thick wing, which I do. Nyx is very close to a “perfect” matte eyeliner. If you’re prone to messing with your eyes you need to be more mindful when wearing this liner or else you’ll end up with empty bits where it has flaked off. Overall, if you apply a thinner layer it has better staying power and looks nice and matte.

Fast shipping and great color

I purchased several eyeliners one day, about a month ago, of different colors. I pulled them out of their box to put away but didn’t want to open them until I needed to use them. I opened this one to use it a couple days ago and it was empty. So make sure if you purchase them you check to make sure it isn’t empty or dried out.

Kinda what I expected for the price. This dries out fast - you have to be putting it on the second you take it out or back in the tube. I can barely do one line before it's like paste. The product in the tube is already getting dry and its not like I leave the top off for more than a second. I am not sure this is totally full.The color (white) is really bright! That's not always easy to find.It lasts a long time, but starts to get crumbly.It dries fast on my eyelid - no time for mistakes.The value = the quality, so...

This stuff stays on for two to three days! Even after I gently wash my face, it is still there…. and that don’t make me mad!