THESAEMEco Soul Powerproof Super Slim Eyeliner - Smudge Proof Gel Eyeliner - Micro Precision Tip (2mm) - Highly Pigmented & Long-lasting Eye Makeup Glides on Smoothly, 0.1g (BK02 Ash Black)

I ordered the THESAEM Super Slim Eyeliner in "ash black" and almost returned it immediately because both the packaging and the pencil appeared brown. However, I decided to try it out, and thankfully, it actually was the ash black I wanted, pairing nicely with my eyeshadow. The eyeliner isn't the highest quality—missing details like a freshness seal on the lid—but it does stay put all day, applies smoothly, and feels good on the skin. It's not as thin as other "super slim" eyeliners I've used, but it applies neatly without much smudging, which is a plus. While I'm more satisfied with this than my previous eyeliner, I'm still on the fence about repurchasing.

Goes on okay and stays decently well. I'm not in love or anything but for the price and good ingredients I'd buy it again.

I’ve been ordering this eyeliner.. probably over 50 times in few years!Only eyeliner I can use without worrying about smudgingStrongly Recommend

This eyeliner is decent considering its price point, but it doesn't quite match the quality of Shiseido

This eyeliner is absolutely beautiful, it is so rich and pigmented! This is twist up gel eyeliner and it is the best brown liner I have used.This eyeliner glides on so easily absolutely no pulling or tugging at your eye. The brown color is so rich and even has little flecks of gold glitter which I didn't know before I tried it out. You get a good amount of eyeliner in the pencil and it doesn't require sharpening, you just twist it up the stick when it starts to dull or seem low.I have used many brown eyeliners before and I have an issue with my eyes watering throughout the day plus I wear contacts. Most eyeliners I have used in the past flake by the end of the day getting in my eye and on my contacts which is very irritating to my eyes, or the color just completely comes off due to my watering eyes. However this eyeliner not only does not flake but, is VERY waterproof, it comes of pretty easily with a cleansing balm but, I did need to scrub alittle with a makeup wipe. This eyeliner looks beautiful from the time I put it on until I take it off at night.This eyeliner is very comfortable to wear and there is no bleeding or smudging under my eye during the day. This eyeliner does not irritate my eyes or contacts. The only issue with this eyeliner is it does not stay on my waterline but, it is not meant as a waterline eyeliner so that is ok and honestly I have never found an eyeliner that does last on my waterline.Overall this is the perfect brown gel liner and it looks gorgeous all day! I definitely recommend if you want a quality eyeliner you give this one a try!

nice rich dark brown eyeliner that is smooth to draw. would have given five stars if it had a sharpener and smudgey tip. its a retractable eyeliner but doesnt stay sharp. it does stay put though so if u wanna smudge it out u have to do it quickly

The online description is 110% accurate when it states this product is smudge proof! I tried on my hand first and tried and tried to rub it off with my fingers. This will not smear or smudge....excellent!The product easily glides on to my skin. Super easy to apply. Didn't have to make several passes to get complete coverage on my face. Easy to use!I ordered the bro5 color. I really like the color, but think the color of the product received looks more like the bro3 color shown in the online photos. This could have to do with my personal skin tone, though? One color can look like entirely different colors on different people based on their skin tones. GREAT color for me. Really like the color.My only concern is there is not much product in the pencil. I rolled out the eye pencil as far as it would go to see how much product it actually contains. Was quite surprised by how little actual pencil/product there is given the length of the actual tube. I'm hoping the product lasts longer than I am expecting. Since it glides on so smoothly and evenly with just one pass I'm hoping I won't go through as much product as I do with my typical eyeliner.Other than that I LOVE this product and it's a very fair price.

This shade of brown is perfect for cool-toned looks, even though it's a brown shade. It's a great choice for those who want a natural look but still want some definition in their eyes. The color is highly pigmented and long-lasting, so you don't have to worry about it smudging or fading throughout the day.Overall, I think this eyeliner is a great product that I would recommend to anyone who wants a high-quality eyeliner that is easy to use and provides great results.