Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner, Deep Charcoal, Eye Pencil, Creamy Formula, Long-Lasting, Waterproof, Smudge-Proof, Fragrance-Free, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free, 0.04 Oz.

This has been my favorite eyeliner for most of a decade now. Yes, in mulberry--I have green eyes and this looks great (and subtle) with natural eyeshadow tones. I have gotten compliments from everyone who notices it. "Is that purple eyeliner?!? It looks great!!! What is it?!?"It's not boldly purple but if you have green eyes and wear a lot of natural-toned eyeshadow, this is an excellent choice.This liner doesn't really smudge at all... but if you want to, you *can* soften it a bit with a fingertip *immediately* after application. But eyeshadow brushes don't usually affect it and, once it has had a minute or two to set, I usually need micellar water or makeup remover to edit it.

This is my favorite brand of makeup out there. I've been using their products for a few years ever since trying a beauty subscription box. It stays on your face all night and doesn't smudge. You can even wake up the next day to roll out of bed and it's still there. It's one of the easier eyeliners to use. It's smooth and doesn't scratch your eyes. I'm going to end up getting a few other colors too! Even better, Amazon's price is really awesome as normally it's even more expensive.

This very dark green is a great color for me when I want to vary slightly from my typical black eyeliner. The smooth application is just what I was looking for.

I had been looking for a dark blue eyeliner with no luck and came upon this one. I was hesitant to purchase because I have very sensitive eyes and have to be careful what makeup I use on them. So far I have had no problem with sensitivity. The color is exactly what I wanted. The color doesn’t fade throughout the day. Overall I’m very pleased with this purchase and have ordered several. I did only give it four stars because it could apply a little easier, maybe if the formula was a little more creamy.

I did not realize that it was .04oz when I bought it. Only lasted for a few weeks. Lovely color and went on easily but for the price, did not last long.

Great eyeliner! It goes on smooth and is very vibrant. Just what I was looking for. It came a day early. Well worth the price. This is my go to brand for eyeliner.

This is the first time I bought this product. And I just tried it for the first time. It goes on so easily and is so silky. I don't know yet how well it will last throughout the day but so far it's my new favorite!

I gave this 2 stars only because I really loved the metal green color! That’s the only positive about it , however!Cons:1. This is NOT at all hypoallergenic! The first time I wore it, I noticed that my eyes were slightly red that night, but thought maybe it was the ragweed pollen floating around. By the third time I wore it, I couldn’t even wait to get home to take it off! I grabbed a wet wipe and removed it ASAP! Red, very itchy, watery eyes! I waited a couple days and decided to try it around the house, but it only lasted a few minutes before I had another allergic reaction.2. It smudges really easily.3. It doesn’t stay on long.I’m returning it!